20 / 2301

Academic integrity matters, but students shouldn’t be penalised for using AI | Letter

TL;DR

Berthold Schoene responds after the head of Ofqual said students could be disqualified from GCSEs and A-levels if they tried to use AI in assessed coursework Is this really the best we can do: draconically penalise the young for making use of the latest cognitive resources and tools available to them (Ofqual urges ‘life-altering’ penalties for students who use tech to cheat, 18 November)? Our generation has allowed the introduction of “life-altering” new technologies into every walk of life without much democratic debate, public scrutiny or governmental oversight.

Nauti's Take

The source base is thin: this is primarily a reader letter, while Ofqual’s exact policy still needs to be checked separately. Schools and education teams should first define a traceable process: which AI use must be documented, and which parts of the work must be demonstrably produced independently in a conversation or supervised setting.

Sources