Writing is an exercise in the art of persuasion. If we use AI we lose the art | Alan Finkel
TL;DR
Every reader deserves to be informed about whether what they are reading is human or AI A few weeks ago, Dr Kylie Moore-Gilbert, an academic in political science at Macquarie University, wrote an opinion piece in the Sydney Morning Herald in which she reported on excessive use of AI chatbots by students to write their essays. In it, she raised her concern that universities are qualifying lawyers, nurses, financial advisers, engineers and teachers who do not have the essential skills required to perform their roles.
Nauti's Take
The uncomfortable bit is right: AI can polish prose, but it does not replace the muscle of building an argument yourself. If you build tools for education or knowledge work, don't just measure output.
Make the thinking trace visible, or you'll optimize assessments for pretty text while hollowing out the skill underneath.
Sources